Publications

Growing credit unions in Britain

Opportunities for shared infrastructure


While Great Britain’s credit union sector has experienced growth over the last decade, it remains small and fragmented relative to comparable movements in Ireland, Canada, and the US. Between 2014 and 2025, the number of British credit unions fell from 359 to 203, while assets more than doubled to £2.8bn. Yet fewer than 4% of British adults are members, compared with over 70% in Ireland and 30% in Canada. Rising costs, thin margins, and limited liquid capital mean most credit unions lack the scale to invest alone in the technology, products, and expertise they need to grow.

Shared infrastructure creates a pathway to achieving necessary economies of scale while maintaining credit unions’ independence and community roots. The policy context is supportive of shared infrastructure: in February 2026, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) announced rule changes which define the amount credit unions can invest in credit union service organisations (CUSOs) and provide further regulatory scaffolding for growing shared infrastructure. The Financial Inclusion Strategy, released in November 2025, created a £30m Credit Union Transformation Fund to invest in shared services and collaboration initiatives.

This report builds on this momentum by contributing a strategic view on how the shared infrastructure ecosystem in Britain can develop to support the sector’s strength and resilience. It draws on 22 domestic and international stakeholder interviews, as well as desktop research and breakeven analysis. Credit union leaders, trade bodies, regulators, and teams within the government who are responsible for delivering the Transformation Fund and policy focused on co-operative finance and financial inclusion can use the findings set out in this report to shape how shared infrastructure develops over the next few years. This report is part of the United Vision project, a joint research programme delivered in partnership between NEF and Swoboda Research Centre. The research topic came out of initial engagement with the sector, through findings which a lack of collaboration was identified as a significant barrier to growth.

  • The preconditions for collaboration are not yet in place. The sector needs stronger board and management capability, trust between institutions, a greater appetite for risk, more active engagement with regulators, and modern core technology.
  • Design matters as much as ambition. Past collaborative efforts, including the Credit Union Expansion Project (CUEP) in Britain and ILCUTech Standard Information System (ISIS) in Ireland, and the more recent experience of centrals in Canada, show us that success relies on narrowly defined scopes, realistic timelines, and strong business cases, as well as appropriate governance structures. The Canadian example offers a warning lesson for how shared models come under strain as the incentives for collaboration between large and small credit unions diverge.
  • Governance, pricing, and exit arrangements must be agreed from the outset. Duplication must also be avoided, because the British system is too small to sustain competing CUSOs.
  • Small, needs-based services are viable now; a central finance facility is not. For example, a shared compliance and internal audit CUSO could break even with around 18 member credit unions, each saving roughly £8,000 a year. A central finance facility, by contrast, would need around £2.3bn under management. That is close to the whole sector’s assets.

RECOMMENDATIONS

  • Short term (0 – 2 years): All Together Money should convene an independently chaired, sector-wide CUSO strategy. This would include a market study, minimum governance standards, and a public register of CUSOs. Alongside this, credit unions should build board capability and start with services that need few members to break even. Trade bodies and other collaborative networks should support them with shared legal templates and competition-law guidance.
  • Medium term (2 – 5 years): Fair4All Finance, working with All Together Money and sector partners, should set clear criteria for the CUSO workstream of the Transformation Fund. Explore low-cost public finance for capital-intensive projects and partnerships with the wider mutual sector. The PRA should review the investment cap based on evidence.
  • Long term (5+ years): Larger credit unions, in partnership with trade bodies and with input from the PRA, should lead work to lay the groundwork for deeper integration, including a possible federated model, and revisit the central finance facility as the sector matures.

If you value great public services, protecting the planet and reducing inequality, please support NEF today.


Make a one-off donation

£5 £10 £25 £50 £100
£

Make a monthly donation

£3 £5 £10 £25 £100
£